A timeless Bahamian beauty, Captain’s Cottage is a wonderful quarry stone house of significant historical value and charm. Blending a storied past with refined island living and crafted to endure while designed to inspire, the home offers a sanctuary of natural beauty, artisanal materials, and modern comforts creating an exceptional retreat where legacy and luxury exist in perfect harmony. Located on the exceptionally picturesque Crown Street, the home is surrounded by vibrant bougainvillea and palm trees cascading over property walls. One of three homes originally left to the daughters of Captain Albury, Captain’s Cottage is a registered historic property and benefits from a transferable property tax exemption. The residence offers approximately 2,200 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, featuring two bedrooms and two bathrooms. The chef’s kitchen includes a sleek all-stainless design and is fully equipped for island entertaining. Outdoor living spaces include a covered patio and an expansive upper deck with harbour views, ideal for enjoying sunsets.
This property for sale is located at Harbour Island in Eleuthera. It was last modified on February 16th 2026. Let us connect you with one of our real estate agents to schedule a viewing or to learn more about Bahamas real estate.

Listing provided by COLDWELL BANKER LIGHTBOURN REA.
Want more information or schedule a showing? Let us put you in touch with the listing agent.